Most drivers think of rust as a cosmetic problem: scruffy sills, a tired underbody, a lower trade-in price. Swedish research shows that, once it reaches the structure, it can be more serious than that.
In 2018 the Swedish insurer Folksam, together with the homeowners’ association Villaägarna, did something that had not been done before. They took two used car models with rust damage and crash-tested them to the same Euro NCAP protocol the models had passed when new: a frontal impact and a side impact, plus a pole test on one of them. Every car had been in daily use and had passed its roadworthiness inspection.
What the tests showed
The two cars gave two different answers, and both matter.
The moderately rusty car looked bad on the outside, but its inner load-bearing structure was not affected. In the crash tests it performed no differently from a new example of the same model.
The severely corroded car was a different story. Several structural beams had been weakened by rust, and its crash protection fell clearly: from four stars to three. Folksam’s researchers put that at roughly 20 per cent higher risk of death or serious injury in a collision.
Their conclusion was that it is not rust as such that matters, but where it sits. Surface rust on outer panels did not change the result. Rust that had eaten into the beams that absorb crash energy did.
What this means on Irish roads
Wet weather, coastal air and salted winter roads are the same conditions that produced those Swedish test cars. Rust rarely starts on a panel you can see. It starts inside sills, box sections and chassis seams, and it has usually been working for years before it reaches a structural member.
Corrosion protection cannot repair a weakened beam, and no coating guarantees how a car will perform in a crash. What cavity wax and underbody coating can do is keep sound metal sound, so the structure never gets to the condition of that second test car. The earlier a vehicle is protected and the better it is prepared before coating, the more that holds.
Browse the Mercasol protection range, or ask us what your vehicle needs.
Source: Folksam press release “Kraftig rost ger sämre krockskydd”, 10 April 2018 (Folksam / Villaägarna used-car crash tests).
